Ɗan gajeren amsa
Idan kana tambaya "shin ya kamata in ƙaura daga Google Drive zuwa Proton Drive?", tambayar da ke bayan tambayar yawanci tana raba zuwa shari'o'i biyu:
Shari'a A — Kana kulawa da sirri musamman. Ee, sauyawa. Proton Drive yana ɓoye fayilolinku a na'urarka kafin loda; Google Drive ba haka yake yi ba. Wannan ba bambanci na fasali ba ne — bambanci ne na tushen ginin. Babu abin da Google ke yi da 2FA ko "ƙa'idojin ƙungiya" da zai rufe wannan giɓi. Idan sirri yana da mahimmanci, kana amfani da samfur inda mai ba da sabis a zahiri ba zai iya karanta fayilolinku ba, ba wanda ya rantse ba sa karanta su.
Shari'a B — Kana kulawa da fasalulluka + haɗin gwiwa. Google Drive har yanzu yana cin nasara a wannan ɓangaren. Google Docs tare da gyaran haɗin gwiwa na lokaci-guda yana da inganci na gaske, manhajojin wayar hannu na Google suna da inganci fiye, kuma tsarin ɓangare na uku (haɗin gwiwa na Zapier, manhajoji na CAD, kayan aikin ƙira) yana da faɗi. Proton Docs yana da kyau don 2024 amma shekara 2-3 a baya.
Yawancin mutane suna haɗe. Don yanayin tsakiya: sauyawa don fayiloli masu mahimmancin sirri (takardu na haraji, rikodin likitanci, shaidu na asali, hotuna na sirri) da kiyaye Google don takaddun aiki na haɗin gwiwa da kake raba su da waɗanda ba sa amfani da Proton. Amfani da duka biyun lokaci ɗaya yana da kyau — wannan ba yanke shawara ta komai ko komai ba ne.
Sauran wannan labarin shine kwatankwacin gaskiya mai cikakkun bayanai don ka iya daidaita waɗanne yanayi suka dace da halin daka.
Tsaro da ɓoyewa — bambanci na gaske
Duka ayyukan biyu suna ɓoye bayanai lokacin da ake hutawa a sabobin su da kuma yayin canja wurin ta HTTPS. Inda suke bambanta shine wanda ke riƙe da makullin ɓoyewa.
Proton Drive
An ɓoye fayilolinku a na'urarka tare da makullan da aka samo daga kalmar sirri ta asusunka. Blobs ɗin da aka ɓoye sune abin da ke tafiya zuwa sabobin Proton. Proton ba ta da makullin ɓoyewa. Idan an kutsa sabobin Proton, maharin yana samun ciphertext. Idan Proton ta karɓi umarni na kotu, zai iya mika ciphertext amma ba zai iya ɓoye shi ba. Idan ma'aikacin Proton ya yi karkataccen aiki, suna ganin ciphertext.
Wannan shine ɓoyewa ta "sifiri-damar samun" ko "sifiri-ilimi." Ita ce tsarin ginin da ba ya bambanta da manajan kalmar sirri da aka kafa yadda ya kamata (Bitwarden, Proton Pass), kamar Signal, kamar iCloud's Advanced Data Protection.
Cikakkun bayanai na fasaha: AES-256 ɓoyewa da tabbatarwa, makullan da aka samo ta KDF mai ƙarfi (Argon2id), makullan asymmetric don raba. Proton yana buga takaddun ƙirar ɓoyewa a proton.me/blog/protondrive-security. An yi nazari a waje (Securitum, 2023).
Musanyar: idan ka manta kalmar sirrinka kuma ka rasa jimlolin dawo da ka, fayilolinku sun tafi. Babu wanda a Proton zai iya taimaka maka. Wannan ba kuskure ba ne — ita ce dukiyar da ke sa ɓoyewa ta sifiri-damar samun ta zama ta sifiri-damar samun a zahiri.
Google Drive
Google Drive yana ɓoye fayiloli lokacin da ake hutawa a sabobin Google. Google kuma yana riƙe da makullin ɓoyewa. Wannan yana nufin:
- Hanyoyin ML na Google suna karanta fayilolinku. Ganowa na phishing na Gmail, fasalin "nemo takaddun da suka shafi" na Drive, bincike mai tushe a abubuwan da ke cikin Google Photos — waɗannan duka suna buƙatar tsarin Google su karanta abubuwan da ke cikin ku.
- Ƙungiyoyin bot na manufofi na Google suna duba fayilolinku. Ganowa ta atomatik na CSAM, ganowa na tashin hankali, da hanyoyin tilasta TOS suna duba abin da kuke loda. Ƙarya na wanzu — shari'ar San Francisco ta 2022 mai fara-fara (uba da aka nuna a matsayin mai laifi saboda hotuna da ya aika zuwa likitan yaro ɗinsa) ta zama labari na ƙasar.
- Buƙatun kotu suna mayar da fayiloli a bayyane. Google yana karɓar ɗaruruwan dubban buƙatun bayanai na gwamnati a shekara kuma yana biyan mafi yawansu. Sun buga rahoton gaskiya. Abin da suka mika shine abubuwan da ke cikin fayiloli da ba a ɓoye su ba.
- Masu gudanar da Workspace za su iya ganin komai. Idan Google Drive ɗinka yana ɓangare na asusun Workspace (aiki/makaranta), mai gudanarwa yana da damar bincike ga komai da ka taɓa adanawa.
Google ba ya ƙaryata komai daga cikin wannan. Littafin farin su ya bayyana a sarari cewa "Google na iya samun damar abubuwan da ke cikin mai amfani don manufofi na musamman ciki har da ba da sabis, samar da tsaro da hana ɓarna, da bin tsarin shari'a."
Hukunci game da ɓoyewa: Proton Drive yana da inganci fiye ta fuskar tsarin sirri. Google Drive yana iya samun damar fiye ta fuskar tsarin (ga Google, ga ƙungiyoyin bot na Google, ga wajibin shari'a na Google). Wannan ba giɓin fasali ba ne — giɓin ƙira ne. Ba ya rufe da 2FA ko matakan biyan kuɗi.
Farashi
Kwatanta apples-to-apples a mataki na 200 GB inda mafi yawan masu amfani suke tsayawa.
| Shiri | Proton Drive | Google One |
|---|---|---|
| Kyauta | 2 GB | 15 GB (da aka raba tare da Gmail + Photos) |
| 100 GB | — | $1.99/wata |
| 200 GB | $3.99/wata | $2.99/wata |
| 500 GB | An haɗa da Proton Unlimited ($12.99/wata, ya haɗa da Mail + VPN + Pass + Calendar) | — |
| 2 TB | An haɗa da Proton Unlimited idan kai kaɗai kake amfani (1 TB kowannenku har zuwa iyali 6) | $9.99/wata |
| Raba iyali | Ee (masu amfani 6 a Proton Family) | Ee (masu amfani 6 a Google One) |
| Rage farashi na shekara | ~17% vs wata-wata | ~17% vs wata-wata |
Abubuwan da aka ɗauka:
- Kai tsaye 200 GB na Drive kadai: Google shine mafi arha da $1/wata ($2.99 vs $3.99). Bambancin $12/shekara. Ba abin yanke shawara ba.
- Proton Unlimited shine mafi ingancin abin da ka samu. A $12.99/wata kana samun 500 GB na ajiya ɓoye + Proton Mail + Proton VPN + Proton Pass + Proton Calendar. Idan a nan gaba za ka biyi ~$5-10/wata don VPN, manajan kalmar sirri, ko imel ɓoye, Unlimited zai biya kansa da sauri.
- Matakan kyauta suna bambanta a amfani. 15 GB na Google kyauta an raba ta tsakanin Drive + Gmail + Photos, wanda ke cika da sauri idan kana amfani da Gmail sosai. 2 GB na Proton kyauta karami ne amma ya isa don gwada gogewa.
Kwatankwacin fasalulluka kai tsaye
| Fasali | Proton Drive | Google Drive |
|---|---|---|
| Ɓoyewa daki-daki | ✅ Ta tsoho, koyaushe tana kunna | ❌ A'a |
| Abokin ciniki mai buɗe mai suna | ✅ (tebur, wayar hannu, yanar gizo) | ❌ Rufe |
| Loda / sauke fayil | ✅ Girman fayil mara iyaka zuwa iyakar shiri | ✅ Max 5 TB kowane fayil |
| Haɗawa da babban fayil (tebur) | ✅ Windows, macOS, Linux | ✅ Windows, macOS, ChromeOS |
| Samun damar ba tare da intanet ba (wayar hannu) | ✅ Yiwa fayiloli alama don samun da offline | ✅ Mai sassauci fiye |
| Gyaran haɗin gwiwa | ⚠️ Docs + Sheets, shekara 2-3 a baya | ✅ Mafi kyau a cikin ajinsa |
| Sharhi a fayiloli | ✅ (ɓoye) | ✅ |
| Tarihin sigar | ✅ Sigar 10+ da aka kiyaye | ✅ Kwana 30+ da aka kiyaye |
| Hanyoyin haɗin raba fayil | ✅ Ɓoye daki-daki ga masu karɓa na Proton, hanyoyin haɗin da aka kare da kalmar sirri ga waɗanda ba na Proton ba | ✅ Izini masu inganci |
| Ƙarewar hanyar haɗin | ✅ | ✅ |
| Raba da aka kare da kalmar sirri | ✅ | ✅ (biyan kuɗi) |
| Haɗin gwiwa na ɓangare na uku | ⚠️ Iyakantacce | ✅ Dubbai (Zapier, Figma, Slack, Notion, da sauransu) |
| Gudanar da ƙungiya/Workspace | ✅ (Proton Business) | ✅ (Google Workspace) |
| Yankin aikin shari'a | 🇨🇭 Switzerland | 🇺🇸 Amurka |
| Lambar uwar garken buɗe mai suna | ❌ | ❌ |
| Manhaji na hotuna na musamman | ❌ (Proton Drive yana adana su kawai) | ✅ Google Photos tare da bincike na AI, ƙwaƙwalwar ajiya, da sauransu |
Inda Google ke cin nasara a zahiri
Google Docs yana da inganci ta yadda Proton Docs ba ta isa ba tukuna. Gyaran haɗin gwiwa na lokaci-guda a takadda mai shafuka 50 tare da mutane 5 da ke gyara yana aiki ba tare da kuskure ba a Google; a Proton Docs, yana aiki amma tare da ɓata lokaci kaɗan na haɗawa da ƙarancin fasalulluka masu yawa. Nau'in ginshiƙi, tebur madubi, macros, ƙari — duka sun ci gaba fiye da a Google.
Google Photos samfur ne daban amma yana raba ajiya da Drive. Bincike ta AI mai amfani da fuska / abubuwa / yanayi yana da amfani sosai kuma ba shi da abin kwatankwaci a Proton Drive (Proton Drive yana adana hotuna amma ba ya bincika su — ta ƙira, tun da ba za su iya ganin abubuwan da aka ɓoye ba).
Tsarin ɓangare na uku — Google Drive yana haɗawa da kowane kayan aikin SaaS. Zapier, IFTTT, Notion, Airtable, mafi yawan manhajoji na CAD, kayan aikin ƙira, kayan aikin lissafin kuɗi, CRMs — duka suna magana da Google Drive. Proton Drive ba ta da wannan tsarin.
Ingancin manhajan wayar hannu — Manhajojin Google sun sami sake dubawa na shekara 15+. Na Proton sun sami na shekara 2-4. Giɓin yana bayyana a ƙananan abubuwa kamar sauri na bincike, ƙirƙirar thumbnail, da fitar yadakusan offline.
Inda Proton ke cin nasara a zahiri
Sirri, kamar yadda aka bayyana a sama. Wannan shine babban dalili ɗaya don sauya.
Rukunin da aka haɗa — idan a nan gaba za ka biya don VPN + manajan kalmar sirri + imel mai sirri, Proton Unlimited yana rufe duka huɗu a farashin ɗaya.
Yankin aikin shari'a — Dokar Tarayya ta Switzerland kan Kariyar Bayanai tana cikin mafi ƙarfin dokoki na sirri a duniya. Dokar Amurka (CLOUD Act, Stored Communications Act) tana da ɗan ƙarfi.
Babu ayyukan asusun ta tushe a abubuwan da ke ciki — ba za a iya dakatar da asusunka ba saboda ƙungiyar bot ta ML ta ɗauka hoto na likitanci don wani abu. Proton ba ya iya ganin abin da kake loda.
Abokin ciniki mai buɗe mai suna — manhajoji na tebur da wayar hannu duka suna buɗe mai suna. Zaka iya tabbatar cewa ɓoyewa na faruwa a zahiri.
Haɗin gwiwa na Proton Mail — hanyoyin haɗin Proton Drive da aka aika ta Proton Mail suna da ɗan ƙarin ɓoyewa daki-daki tsakanin masu amfani da Proton.
Raba da haɗin gwiwa
Duka samfuran biyu suna ba ka damar raba fayiloli da:
- Masu amfani na musamman (asusun-zuwa-asusun)
- Hanyoyin haɗin jama'a (kowa da URL)
- Hanyoyin haɗin da aka kare da kalmar sirri
Rabon Proton Drive tsakanin masu amfani da Proton biyu ana ɓoye su daki-daki a ɓangaren biyu — an sake ɓoye fayil da aka raba tare da makullin jama'a na mai karɓa. Idan mai karɓa ba ya a kan Proton, suna samun hanyar haɗin zuwa kallon ɓoyewa a cikin burauzar (makulli yana a cikin ɓangaren URL, don haka sabobin Proton ba za su iya karanta shi ba amma duk maharin da ke da hanyar haɗin zai iya).
Rabon Google Drive yana ba masu karɓa kallon kai tsaye a sabobin Google. Babu bambancin ɓoyewa tsakanin mai raba da mai karɓa — Google yana ganin komai ta kowace hanya.
Don aikin haɗin gwiwa inda kuke buƙatar gyara na lokaci-guda tare da mutane 5+ a takadda, Google Drive har yanzu yana da inganci fiye. Proton Docs yana kama kama amma bai rufe giɓin tukuna ba.
Manhajojin wayar hannu da tebur
iOS
- Proton Drive: Manhaji mai fasali cikakke, buɗe ta biometric, yiwa alama don offline, bincike, loda daga Photos. Yana amfanuwa amma ba ya fafatawa da ingancin Google.
- Google Drive: UI mai kyau fiye, thumbnails mafi sauri, haɗin gwiwa mai ƙarfi na Google Photos + Gmail. Jagora saboda wani dalili.
Android
- Proton Drive: Fasali daidai da sigar iOS. Yana haɗawa da sheet na raba na Android.
- Google Drive: An riga an sanya shi a mafi yawan na'urorin Android; mafi zurfi haɗin gwiwa mai yiwuwa.
Tebur (Windows / macOS / Linux)
- Proton Drive: Abokin ciniki na haɗawa na tebur na asali tun 2024. Goyan bayan Linux yana da inganci fiye da na Google — Google ba ta taɓa aika manhaji na rasmi na Drive na Linux ba (akwai gyare-gyaren "Drive File Stream" + saitunan rclone mara hukuma).
- Google Drive: Manhaji na tebur a Windows / macOS, babu na hukuma a Linux.
Yanar gizo
- Duka biyun suna da inganci.
Sirri da yankin aikin shari'a
Proton Drive Proton AG yana gudanar da shi a Switzerland. Dokar Switzerland:
- Tana buƙatar umarni na kotu don kowane buƙatun bayanai
- Ba za ta iya tilasta Proton karya ɓoyewa da Proton ba ta riƙe makullan ba
- Tana waje da ƙawancen raba bayanai na 14 Eyes
- Tana buga rahoton gaskiya yana nuna buƙatun gwamnati da ayyukan amsawa
Google Drive Google LLC yana gudanar da shi a Amurka. Dokar Amurka:
- CLOUD Act yana ba hukumomin Amurka damar neman bayanai daga kamfanonin Amurka a duniya baki ɗaya ba tare da yardar yankin waje ba
- Takaddun Tsaron Ƙasa suna ba da damar neman bayanai ba tare da kula da shari'a a wasu lokuta ba
- "Ka'idar ɓangare na uku" a tarihi yana nufin bayanai da ka son bawa Google ta hankali suna da ƙarancin kariya ta Kwaskwarima ta Huɗu (yana canzawa ta Carpenter, amma har yanzu yana da rauni fiye da kai tsaye ga mai amfani)
- Google yana buga rahoton gaskiya, wanda ya cika; adadin amsawa ga buƙatun gwamnatin Amurka shine ~80%.
Idan ƙirar barazanarku ta haɗa da "gwamnati da ba na aminta da ita gaba ɗaya tana son fayilolinmu", Switzerland > Amurka.
Idan ƙirar barazanarku shine "masu kutsa suna iya kutsa Google", tsaron gefen uwar garken na Google yana da inganci na gaske kuma kuna iya lafiya ta kowace hanya. Amma masu kutsa-suna-kutsa-Google ba shine babban haɗari ba; shi ne abin da Google (da masu sarrafa ƙasa ta uku ɗinsu) ke yi da fayilolinku a al'ada wanda ke ƙirƙirar bambancin tsarin.
Shawarar mu ta amfani ta amfani
1. Kana aiki da takaddun sirri kuma ba ka yi haɗin gwiwa sosai. Sauya zuwa Proton Drive gaba ɗaya. Za ka ƙasa lura da giɓin fasali don aikin kadaici, kuma ƙarfafawar sirri yana da gaske.
2. Kana cikakke a kan Google Workspace don aiki kuma ba za ka iya ƙaura ba tare da ƙaurar dukan ƙungiyar ba. Ci gaba da amfani da Google Drive don takaddun aiki. Don fayiloli na mutum (dawowar haraji, rikodin likitanci, shaidu na asali, hotuna na iyali da kake kulawa da su), saita asusun Proton Drive na kyauta ko Plus kuma ƙauri waɗannan musamman. Amfani da duka biyun yana aiki.
3. Kana biya don VPN da manajan kalmar sirri daban-daban. Proton Unlimited a $12.99/wata shine mafi ingancin abin da ka samu — kana samun Drive, Mail, VPN, Pass, Calendar, kuma yana arha a zahiri fiye da biya $8 + $3 + $5 don ayyuka uku daban.
4. Kana a tsarin Apple tare da iCloud. Kunna iCloud Advanced Data Protection idan ba ka yi ba tukuna — wannan yana ɗaga tsaron iCloud Drive zuwa matakin Proton, kuma haɗin gwiwa da komai Apple ya riga ya ƙarfu. Proton Drive yana zama mai yawa idan ba ka son ɗorewar Apple.
5. Ɗan daukar hoto / mai ƙirƙirar bidiyo tare da 1 TB+ na kafofin watsa labaru. Proton Unlimited yana ba ka 500 GB; don 1-2 TB kana kallon haɓaka zuwa Proton Family. Google One a $9.99/wata don 2 TB har yanzu yana arha a wannan matakin. Idan sirrin hotuna/bidiyo yana da ƙarancin mahimmanci fiye da tsada, Google yana cin nasara. Idan yana da mahimmanci, biya don Proton.
6. Kai ɗan jarida ne, mai fafutuka, ko kowa da ke sarrafa abubuwa masu hankali. Ba kawai "ya kamata ya sauyawa" ba — ya kamata a ɗauka wajibci. Abubuwan tushe, takaddun shari'a, da bincike mai hankali bai kamata su zauna a kan wani mai ba da sabis da zai iya karanta su ba. Proton Drive tare da kalmar sirri mai ƙarfi, da ƙarin kwafin gida zuwa diski na waje ɓoye, shine mafi ƙarancin buƙata.
Gargaɗin ƙaura da ya kamata a sani
Fayilolin da aka raba da kai ba sa fita cikin tsari. Google Takeout yana haɗa fayiloli da KA MALLAKA kawai. Fayilolin da wasu suka raba da kai suna buƙatar sauke su ɗaya-ɗaya ko sake raba daga mai shi. Wannan shine mafi girman giɓin matsaloli lokacin ƙaura.
Tsarin Google Photos ba ya tsira. Idan asusun Google ɗinka yana da hotuna tare da kundin waƙa na musamman, alamun fuska, da ƙwaƙwalwar da AI ta ƙirƙira, waɗannan duka metadata na samfurin Photos ne — ba abubuwan da ke cikin fayil na gaske ba. Lokacin da ka ƙauri fayiloli zuwa Proton Drive, ka rasa ɗan tsarin. Tsara dabarar tsarin hotuna daban (rukunin Lightroom na gida, sabis ɗin daukar hoto daban kamar Ente ko Immich mai kankanin kai).
Canzawa na fayilolin Ofis. Idan kana da Google Docs (tsarin asali), ba fayiloli masu ɗaukuwa ba ne — tsarin mallakar Google ne wanda kawai ke aiki a cikin Google Docs. Takeout yana fitar da su azaman .docx / .xlsx ta tsoho, wanda Proton Docs zai iya buɗe amma na iya rasa tsari. Duba kowane takaddar da aka canza kafin a goge asalin Google.
Ɗakunan ajiya da aka raba a Workspace. Idan kana cikin ƙungiyar Workspace, "Ɗakunan Ajiya Da Aka Raba" (fayiloli da ƙungiyar ke mallaka, ba kai ba) ba sa fitar ta Takeout na mutum. Za ka buƙatar shigar da mai gudanarwa na ƙungiya.
Ɗan abu ɗaya ƙari — Proton Drive ba ita ce zaɓi ɗaya tilo ba
Wannan labarin yana mayar da hankali kan Proton Drive saboda ita ce mafi shahararren zaɓin mai amfani ɓoye daki-daki. Yana da amfani a san madadin idan Proton ba ta dace ba:
- Tresorit — Switzerland, E2E ɓoye, yana mai da hankali kan ƙungiya. Tsada fiye da Proton, ƙarin fasalullukan gudanar da ƙungiya.
- Sync.com — Kanada, E2E ɓoye, farashi mai fafatawa, ƙarancin suna da sananne.
- pCloud tare da ƙarin Crypto — Switzerland, ɓoyewa E2E kari ne biyan kuɗi a saman shirin biyan kuɗi na yau da kullum. Zai iya zama mai arha don siyan rayuwa ɗaya.
- iCloud Drive tare da Advanced Data Protection — Tsarin Apple, E2E don Drive, Photos, Notes, Backup.
- Kankanin kai — Nextcloud, Seafile, ko OwnCloud a kan VPS ko NAS na gida. Mafi girman sirri, mafi girman nauyin kulawa.
Duba yankin ajiyar fayil ɓoye ɗinmu don kwatankwacin Proton Drive vs Tresorit vs Sync.com mai zurfi fiye.
Mai alaƙa
- Nazarin Proton Drive — nuni mai zurfi kadai
- Kwatankwacin ajiyar fayil ɓoye — kallon masu ba da sabis da yawa mai faɗi
- Imel ɓoye — Proton Mail, Tutanota, Mailbox.org
- Jerin Duba Sirri — duba mataki 20 don asusunka
- Kwatankwacin sirri na tsarin aiki na tebur — tsarin aiki da ajiyar girgije ɗinka ke gudana a kansa yana da mahimmanci ma