Tsallake zuwa babban abun ciki

Proton Pass vs Bitwarden 2026 — Kwatancen Gaskiya

Proton Pass vs Bitwarden — manajan kalmomin sirri biyu mafi ƙarfi na buɗaɗɗen tushe. Tsaro, fasali, farashi, wanda ke zaɓar wanne.

An sabunta shi: 28 Afirilu, 2026

Taƙaitaccen bayani

  • Dukkansu na buɗaɗɗen tushe ne, suna amfani da ɓoyayyen ƙarshe-zuwa-ƙarshe, kuma an gwada su daga waje — kowane ɗaya zaɓi mai kyau ne.
  • **Bitwarden ya fi araha** — matakin kyauta nasa ya ƙunshi kalmomin sirri marasa iyaka, na'urori marasa iyaka, da gudanar da kai; Proton Pass kyauta yana iyakantar ku zuwa akwatuna 10 kuma babu 2FA.
  • **Proton Pass ya fi kyau wajen haɗawa** — idan kuna amfani da Proton Mail/VPN/Drive, ana haɗa shi zuwa asusun guda ɗaya tare da laƙabın imel ɓoyayye da labarin murmurewa tare.
  • **Proton Pass yana da laƙabın imel da aka gina ciki** (salon Hide-My-Email), an haɗa shi kyauta; Bitwarden yana buƙatar ƙari da ake biya (Bitwarden Authenticator / haɗin SimpleLogin).
  • Dukkansu suna ba da shirin kasuwanci/ƙungiya; Bitwarden ya fi balaga a can (SSO, gudanar da masu amfani, SCIM).

Amsawar taƙaice

Idan kana yanke shawara tsakanin Proton Pass da Bitwarden a 2026, kana zaɓar tsakanin manajan kalmomin sirri biyu da ke yin abubuwan asali daidai — ɓoyayyen ƙarshe-zuwa-ƙarshe, lambar buɗaɗɗen tushe, gwaje-gwaje na waje na gaske, da babu tsarin kasuwanci da aka saka da talla. Kowane ɗaya zai kiyaye kalmomin sirrinka da aminci fiye da adana su a burauzar, kuma kowane ɗaya ya fi kyau sosai fiye da sake amfani da kalmomin sirri 5 ɗaya a shafuka 200.

Don haka abin da ke yanke shawara ba "wanne ya fi aminci" — dukkansu suna da ƙarfi. Shi ne wanne ya fi dacewa da rayuwarka:

  • Zaɓi Bitwarden idan: kana son mafi kyawun matakin kyauta da ake samu a ko'ina, kana kula da gudanar da kai, ko kana da daɗin ba tare da laƙabın imel da aka gina ciki ba.
  • Zaɓi Proton Pass idan: kana amfani da Proton Mail/VPN/Drive, kana son laƙabın imel ɓoyayye da aka gina ciki, ko kana son app mai kyakkyawan ƙira akan adadin fasali mara ƙima.

Sauran wannan labarin kwatancen dalla-dalla ne — tsarin tsaro, farashi, fasali, tallafin dandalin, da abubuwan da suka lalace — don ka iya yanke shawara tare da cikakken mahallin.

Tsaro da ɓoyayye

Proton Pass da Bitwarden dukkansu suna aiwatar da irin wannan salon ɓoyayyen: kalmar sirrinka ta master ba ta bar na'urarku ba. Ana turawa ta aikin samo maɓalli (KDF) don ƙirƙirar maɓallin akwatu, kuma kowane abu a cikin akwatunka — kalmar sirri, bayanin kula, katin kuɗi, asirin TOTP — an ɓoye shi da wannan maɓalli ta amfani da AES-256 (musamman AES-256-GCM don Bitwarden, irin wannan yanayin ɓoyayyen da aka tabbatar don Proton Pass). Sannan ana loda toshen ɓoyayye zuwa sabarori, waɗanda za su iya adana su da aiko su amma ba za su iya ɓoye komai ba.

Bambancin aiki:

Bitwarden yana farawa da PBKDF2 tare da maimaitawa 600,000 — KDF mai ƙarfi, tare da ƙa'idodi. Zaka iya canzawa zuwa Argon2id a cikin Saitunan Tsaro idan kana son kariya mai ƙarfi ta ƙwaƙwalwa-hard akan harin brute-force na GPU. Suna buga cikakken takardun fari: bitwarden.com/help/bitwarden-security-white-paper.

Proton Pass yana amfani da Argon2id ta tsoho — mai cin ƙwaƙwalwa-hard na Gasa ta Hashing Kalmar Sirri ta 2015 kuma gabaɗaya ana ɗaukarsa mafi tsayin daka na brute-force fiye da PBKDF2. Takardun fasaharsu suna a proton.me/blog/proton-pass-security-model.

Dukkansu an gwada su daga waje: Gwajin Bitwarden na kwanan nan ya kasance ta Cure53 a 2023; Proton Pass an gwada shi ta Securitum, kuma a 2023. Rahotannin gwaji suna jama'a.

Mai nasara: Dukkansu suna da tsaro a matakin samarwa. Idan kana son KDF mafi kyau a ka ta tsoho, Argon2id na Proton Pass yana ɗan gaba kaɗan — amma kowane tura Bitwarden na zamani da ke amfani da zaɓin Argon2id ɗinsa ya yi daidai.

Farashi

Wannan shine inda biyu suke rarrabuwa sosai.

Bitwarden

  • Kyauta: kayan ajiya na akwatu marasa iyaka, na'urori marasa iyaka, gudanar da kai kyauta, ƙungiyar masu amfani 2 tare da tarin da aka raba. Matakin kyauta yana aiki da gaske don kashi 95% na masu amfani.
  • Premium ($10/shekara): yana ƙara adana lambar 2FA da aka gina ciki (TOTP), haɗe fayiloli har zuwa 5 GB, damar gaggawa, rahotannin tsaro (lafiyar akwatu), da tallafi mai fifiko.
  • Iyali ($47.88/shekara don masu amfani 6): Fasali na Premium don ƙungiyar iyali.
  • Ƙungiyoyi/Kamfani ($3-$6/mai amfani/wata): SSO, tanadi SCIM, allunan gwaji na ci gaba.

Proton Pass

  • Kyauta: kayan ajiya na akwatu marasa iyaka, na'urori marasa iyaka, laƙabın imel 10 na hide-my-email, mai ƙirƙirar kalmar sirri, tallafin passkey. Ana iya amfani da shi da gaske a matsayin direba na yau da kullun — Proton ya cire iyakar tarihi ta abubuwa 10 a ƙarshen 2023.
  • Plus (~$1.99/wata ana ɓiya shekara-shekara, ko $4.99/wata wata-wata — an haɗa shi kyauta da Proton Unlimited a $12.99/wata): laƙabın imel marasa iyaka, mai tabbatar da 2FA da aka gina ciki, raba akwatu mai aminci (har zuwa masu amfani 10), Hanyoyin Aminci, Lura da Yanar gizo Mai Duhu, haɗe fayiloli, Proton Sentinel anti-zamba, Damar Gaggawa, yankunan al'ada don laƙabi, CLI.
  • Iyali na Pass (~$3.99/wata shekara-shekara): asusosi 6 na Pass Plus + allon admin.
  • Kasuwanci ($7.99/mai amfani/wata): gudanar da ƙungiya, akwatuna da aka raba, allunan aiki.

Mai nasara: Bitwarden ya kasance ɗan araha kaɗan ga mutane ɗaya ɗaya ($10/shekara vs ~$24/shekara) kuma shine zaɓi ɗaya idan kana buƙatar gudanar da kai. Proton Pass shine ciniki mafi kyau idan kana riga ka biya don Proton Unlimited — Pass Plus yana aiki a hankali kyauta a cikin wannan haɗin. Tsarin "Pass Kyauta ba za a iya amfani da shi ba" wanda wasu tsofaffin bita suka ɗauko ba ya nan kuma; Kyauta yanzu yana aiki da gaske.

Kwatancen fasali kai-da-kai

Fasali Proton Pass Bitwarden
Kayan ajiya na akwatu marasa iyaka ✅ (Kyauta) ✅ (Kyauta)
Na'urori marasa iyaka ✅ ✅
Ɓoyayyen ƙarshe-zuwa-ƙarshe ✅ ✅
Abokan ciniki na buɗaɗɗen tushe ✅ ✅
Sabar buɗaɗɗen tushe ❌ (gudanar da shi kawai) ✅
Gudanar da kai ❌ ✅
Adana 2FA da aka gina ciki (TOTP) ✅ (Plus) ✅ (Premium)
Laƙabın imel ✅ (10 kyauta, marasa iyaka a Plus) ❌ (haɗin ɓangare na uku kawai)
Tallafin passkey (shiga a matsayin) ✅ ✅
Buɗe akwatu ta passkey ✅ ✅
Kariyar asusu anti-zamba ✅ Proton Sentinel (Plus+) ❌
Raba ɓoyayye na wucin gadi ✅ Hanyoyin Aminci (Plus) ✅ Send (Rubutu kyauta, fayiloli Premium)
Akwatuna da aka raba ✅ (Plus, har zuwa masu amfani 10) ✅ (ƙungiyar masu amfani 2 Kyauta; masu amfani 6 Iyali)
Raba kalmar sirri mai aminci ✅ ✅
Lura da karya ✅ asali (Kyauta), Yanar gizo Mai Duhu cikakke (Plus) ✅ Rahoton Karya ta Bayanan (Kyauta, HIBP)
Haɗe fayiloli ✅ (Plus) ✅ (Premium, 5 GB)
Damar gaggawa ✅ (Plus) ✅ (Premium)
CLI ✅ (Plus, an ƙaddamar a 2025) ✅
Buɗewa ta biometric ✅ ✅
Shirin iyali ✅ (ta Proton Family) ✅ ($47.88/shekara, masu amfani 6)
Allunan aiki / gwaji ❌ (matakin Kasuwanci kawai) ❌ (Ƙungiyoyi/Kamfani kawai)

Ikon laƙabın imel

Wannan shine mafi kyawun fasalin Proton Pass guda ɗaya. Lokacin da kake yi wa sabis ɗin sabo rajista, Proton Pass zai iya ƙirƙirar laƙabi na lokaci guda kamar wk9m7n3@passinbox.com wanda ke juya zuwa imelin ka na gaske. Zaka iya kashe laƙabin a kowane lokaci (spam, karya, kamfani da ba ka yarda da shi kuma), kuma adireshin gaske ya kasance a ɓoye. Proton Pass Kyauta yana haɗa da laƙabın imel 10 na hide-my-email; Plus da Unlimited suna samun marasa iyaka.

Bitwarden yana da haɗin gwiwa da SimpleLogin, addy.io, Firefox Relay, da Fastmail da ke cimma abu ɗaya — amma kuna buƙatar asusun daban tare da kowane ɗaya. Proton yana haɗa shi a asali.

Idan ayyukan laƙabin imel / imel na ƙone suna da mahimmanci gare ka (ya kamata su kasance, don sirri), Proton Pass ya ci wannan rukunin gaba ɗaya.

Ikon gudanar da kai

Wannan shine mafi kyawun fasalin Bitwarden guda ɗaya. Zaka iya gudanar da cikakken sabar Bitwarden a Raspberry Pi, VPS na girgije, ko homelab ɗinka. Akwatunka ɓoyayye ba ya taɓa taɓa sabarori na Bitwarden. Don mafi yawan masu sirri, masu gudanar da tsarin, da duk wanda manufofin kamfaninsa ke hana adana takaddun shaida na girgije na ɓangare na uku, wannan yana da yanke shawara.

Proton Pass yana gudanar da shi kawai. Proton yana gudanar da sabarori a Switzerland, suna da ɓoyayyen E2E, kuma dokar Switzerland tana da kariya mai ƙarfi — amma har yanzu ɓangare na uku ne.

Aikace-aikace da tallafin burauzar

Dukkansu suna rufe manyan dandalin:

  • Aikace-aikacen tebur na Windows, macOS, Linux: dukkansu.
  • Aikace-aikacen wayar hannu na iOS da Android: dukkansu, tare da buɗewa ta biometric da haɗin cike ta atomatik.
  • Ƙarin burauzar: dukkansu suna jigilar don Chrome, Firefox, Edge, Safari, Brave, Opera.
  • CLI: dukkansu — CLI na Bitwarden ya fi balaga; CLI na Proton Pass an ƙaddamar a ƙarshen 2025 (matakai da ake biya).
  • Aikace-aikacen agogo (Apple Watch): dukkansu, karanta kawai.

A amfani na yau da kullun, cike ta atomatik da adana ta atomatik dukkansu suna aiki da aminci. A labari, ƙarin Firefox na Bitwarden ya kasance mafi gwajin fagen yaki mafi tsawo; UX na Proton Pass yana da kyakkyawan ƙira sosai a aikace-aikacen wayar hannu kuma yana ji kamar an tsara shi bayan 2022 (wanda aka yi).

Sirri da ikon yanki

Proton Pass Proton AG ne ke gudanar da shi a Switzerland. Dokar sirri ta Switzerland (musamman Dokar Tarayya akan Kariyar Bayanan) tana cikin mafi ƙarfi a duniya, kuma Proton yana da tarihin buga rahotannin gaskiya na tsawo. An gwada Proton ta ƙungiyoyi na waje akai-akai.

Bitwarden Bitwarden Inc. ce ke gudanar da shi a Amurka, musamman a Florida. Dokar sirri ta Amurka ta fi rauni fiye da dokar Switzerland, amma ɓoyayyen E2E na Bitwarden yana nufin har da buƙatar da kotun Amurka ta yi na bayanan za ta sami ciphertext ɓoyayye kawai. Lambar Bitwarden tana samuwa a ƙarƙashin AGPL da aka gyara / Yarjejeniyar Lasisi na Bitwarden, kuma rahotannin gaskiyar su suna jama'a.

Babu kamfanin da ke da tarihi na haɗin gwiwa da buƙatun sa ido ba tare da tukuici ba, gwargwadon abin da za a iya tabbatarwa a fili. Idan ikon yanki na Switzerland yana da mahimmanci ga tsarin barazanar ka, Proton Pass yana da gaba. Idan kana son guje wa ikon yanki gaba ɗaya, zaɓin gudanar da kai na Bitwarden kawai yana yin hakan.

Amfani da ƙungiya da ƙungiyoyi

Ga mutane ɗaya ɗaya, shirye-shiryen mutum ɗaya na dukkansu suna rufe komai. Ga ƙungiyoyi da ƙungiyoyi, daidaituwa suna da sarƙaƙƙiya fiye da haka.

Bitwarden yana da samfurin ƙungiya mai balaga. Yana ba da SAML/SSO, tanadi masu amfani ta SCIM, aiko kundin adireshi (tare da Azure AD, Google Workspace, Okta, OneLogin, JumpCloud), da manufofin kamfani (buƙatun ƙarfin kalmar sirri, tilasta 2FA). Shirin Ƙungiyoyi shine $3/mai amfani/wata, Kamfani shine $6/mai amfani/wata.

Proton Pass don Kasuwanci ya ƙunshi abubuwan asali: akwatuna na duk ƙungiya, gudanar da masu amfani, rahotannin admin. Ya fi sabo (an ƙaddamar a 2024) kuma har yanzu yana kaiwa SSO da aiko kundin adireshi. An haɗa shi a cikin shirye-shiryen Kasuwanci na Proton ($9.99/mai amfani/wata) wanda kuma ya haɗa da Mail/VPN/Drive na kasuwanci.

Idan kamfaninku yana amfani da Google Workspace ko Microsoft 365 kuma kuna kula da SSO yau, Bitwarden shine zaɓi mafi ƙarancin kulawa. Idan kamfaninku ya cika amfani da ayyukan Proton, Proton Pass don Kasuwanci shine zaɓin haɗin kai.

Abubuwan da suka lalace na duniyar gaske

Wasu abubuwan da ba su dace sosai a cikin tebur na fasali ba:

Murmurewa lokacin da ka manta da kalmar sirrinka ta master. Bitwarden ba shi da murmurewa — idan ka manta da kalmar sirri ta master, ba za a iya murmurewa da akwatun ta ƙira ba. Proton Pass iri ɗaya ne, amma idan kana amfani da asusun Proton, asusunka na Proton yana da murmurewa daban (waya, imel, maɓallin murmurewa). Wannan baya ba ka dawo da kalmar sirri ta Pass da aka manta — yana dawo da kai cikin asusun Proton don ka fara sabon akwatun Pass. Babu ɗaya da shine cikakken hanyar "sake saita kalmar sirri" a ma'anar gargajiya.

Ɗaukar bayanan fita. Dukkansu suna tallafawa fitar da CSV mai tsabta. Bitwarden kuma yana tallafawa fitar da JSON tare da cikakken amincin akwatu (manyan fayiloli, haɗe fayiloli, bayanin kula). Proton Pass yana fitar da CSV da tsarin ajiya ɓoyayye. Babu ɗaya da ke kulle ka ciki.

Damar layi. Bitwarden yana da ingantaccen yanayin layi — bayan aiko, zaka iya buɗewa da karanta akwatunka ba tare da hanyar sadarwa ba. Proton Pass yana da karanta layi amma yana buƙatar hanyar sadarwa don kowane aiki na rubuta, tunda canje-canje dole ne su wuce ta sabarori na Proton.

Cike ta atomatik na katin kuɗi / asalin mutum. Dukkansu suna tallafawa shi. Aiwatarwar Bitwarden tana da ɗan ƙarin dalla-dalla (abubuwa daban don asalin mutum vs. kati, adiresoshi da yawa ga asalin mutum ɗaya). Proton Pass yana kula da komai a matsayin "abubuwa tare da filayen da aka rubuta".

Kula da TOTP. Dukkansu za su iya adana asirin TOTP a cikin akwatun kuma cike lambar lambobi 6 ta atomatik. Wasu ƙwararrun tsaro suna ba da shawarar adawa da wannan a kan dalili cewa idan an lalace akwatunka, ɓangarorin biyu suna fadi a lokaci ɗaya — amma ga yawancin masu amfani, sauƙi yana inganta karɓar 2FA sosai, wanda shine nasara ta tsaro gaba ɗaya.

Shawarar mu

Ga mai amfani da ke mai da hankali kan sirri a 2026, ga bishiyar yanke shawara mai tsabta:

  1. Kana amfani da Proton Mail, VPN, ko Drive a shirin da ake biya → Proton Pass. An haɗa shi kyauta, laƙabın imel suna haɗawa da ƙusa, kuma kana samun labarin murmurewa ɗaya haɗe.
  2. Kana son mafi kyawun manajan kalmomin sirri kyauta, gaba ɗaya → Bitwarden. Abubuwa marasa iyaka kyauta, da gudanar da kai kyauta idan kana son shi.
  3. Kana gudanar da kayan aikin ka kanka kuma kana son kulawa → Bitwarden (gudanar da kai).
  4. Kana son mafi yawan sirrin laƙabin imel / imel na ƙone → Proton Pass.
  5. Kana aiki a kamfani da ke buƙatar SSO / SCIM / aiko kundin adireshi yau → Bitwarden Enterprise.
  6. Kana cika amfani da Proton kuma kana son biyan kuɗi ɗaya → Proton Pass (ta Proton Unlimited).

Dukkan kayayyakin za su kiyaye kalmomin sirrinka da aminci fiye da duk abin da kake yi yanzu idan ba ka amfani da manajan kalmomin sirri kwata-kwata. Mafi munin zaɓi shine babu zaɓi.

Masu alaƙa

Yadda ake ƙaurace daga Bitwarden zuwa Proton Pass

Ƙaurace mai aminci na mintuna 5 da ke kiyaye lambobin TOTP, tsarin manyan fayiloli, da abubuwan da aka haɗe.

  1. Fitar da akwatunka na Bitwarden a matsayin CSV:A cikin akwatun yanar gizo na Bitwarden, je zuwa Kayan aiki → Fitar da Akwatu → zaɓi tsarin `.csv` → shigar da kalmar sirrinka ta master → Fitar. Za ka sami fayil mai suna `bitwarden_export_YYYY-MM-DD.csv`. Kiyaye wannan tab a buɗe; KA RUFE burauzar YET.
  2. Ƙirƙiri asusunka na Proton Pass (ko shiga):Ziyarci proton.me/pass kuma yi rajista don asusun kyauta ko Plus. Idan kana amfani da Proton Mail/VPN/Drive, sharuɗɗan guda ɗaya suna aiki. Saita kalmar sirri mai ƙarfi ta master — wannan ita ce maɓalli ɗaya da ke kare akwatunka, don haka mai tsawo da na musamman yi shi.
  3. Shigo da CSV na Bitwarden:A cikin yanar gizo na Proton Pass → Saitunan → Shigo da → Zaɓi Bitwarden → Loda fayil ɗin CSV → Duba abubuwan da aka gano → Tabbatar. Proton Pass zai ɓoye CSV a cikin gida, sake ɓoye kowane abu tare da maɓallin akwatu na Proton Pass ɗinka, kuma loda. Yawanci yana ɗaukar dakiku 30-60 don abubuwa 500-1000.
  4. Tabbatar da lambobin TOTP suna aiki har yanzu:Buɗe asusosi 3-5 da ke amfani da 2FA a cikin Proton Pass kuma tabbatar da lambar lambobi 6 da aka nuna ta dace da abin da shafukan yanar gizo ke tsammanin. Asirin TOTP an kiyaye shi a cikin fitar da CSV amma wani lokaci laƙabi marar dacewa yana haifar da shigowa cikin abu maras daidai — gwada kafin ka dogara.
  5. Duba tsarin manyan fayiloli:Fitar da Bitwarden ya haɗa da bayanan meta na "manyan fayiloli"; Proton Pass yana taswira waɗannan zuwa "akwatuna". Duba yadda aka tsara akwatunka kuma sake suna duk abin da yake da laƙabi marar kyau. Zaka iya ja-da-saki abubuwa tsakanin akwatuna bayan shigowa.
  6. Share fitar da CSV da aminci:Wannan yana da mahimmanci — CSV yana ƙunshe da kowane kalmar sirri a fili. A macOS/Linux gudanar da `shred -u bitwarden_export_*.csv`; a Windows, yi amfani da SDelete daga Sysinternals ko Eraser. Fanye Recycle Bin bai isa ba.
  7. Fita daga Bitwarden a na'urori tsofaffi:Bitwarden → Saitunan → Fita, a duk na'urar da aka shiga. Wannan yana soke alamun zaman tsofaffi. Kiyaye asusunka na Bitwarden a raye na kwanaki 30 idan ka gano abubuwa da suka ɓace bayan ƙaurace — sannan share shi lokacin da kake tabbatacce.
  8. Gwada shiga na gaske a wayar hannu da tebur:Sanya Proton Pass a wayarka (App Store / Play Store) da tebur (kari ɗin burauzar don Chrome/Firefox/Safari/Edge), shiga, kuma da gaske shiga shafuka 3-5 ta amfani da cike ta atomatik. Kama matsalolin UX a rana ta 1 ya fi ganowa a lokacin shiga mai mahimmanci.

Tambayoyin Da Ake Yawan Yi